Gurumurthy on the Vijayakanth factor

S.Gurumurthy in the New Indian Express on the Vijayakanth factor in this election:

Imagine if the AIADMK alliance had roped in DMDK. How many seats would Vijayakant have shifted to the AIADMK alliance from the DMK alliance? Hold your breath, 105 seats, assuming that he shifted all his votes to the alliance!

Yes, if the AIADMK alliance had brought in Vijayakant into its calculus it would have won not 69 seats, but 171. Imagine this had taken place, what would have been the tally of the DMK. Just 53 seats instead of 96 it won! How about the Congress? Just 3 instead of 37! PMK? Just one instead of 17! CPM? Again, just one, instead of 9! CPI? None instead of 7! Unbelievable, yet, true.

He goes on to say that Karunanidhi would have taken Vijayakanth in if he were leading ADMK, and credits him with identifying that this election would be won or lost by sheer alliances:

The way Karunanidhi structured the DMK-led alliance indicated his understanding of the mood of the people. He judged that there was no anti-incumbency, nor any pro-incumbency, mood in people. He knew that Jayalalithaa had vastly improved her position in the last two years and so he needed the alliance even more now than in the 2004 Lok Sabha elections. So he rooted for electoral physics.

In contrast, save for her wooing Vaiko, Jayalalithaa relied more on electoral chemistry to overcome the effect of electoral physics. Perhaps she was also influenced by pollsters who had initially predicted her victory. The result was that she left out Vijayakant and thus did not complete the process of bipolar contest.Thus, the election threw up the Vijayakant space between the bipolar alliances incomplete on one side. The result was what should have been a resounding victory for her alliance turned into a defeat brought about by an omission, and a costly one at that. It is Karunanidhi's greater reliance on the power of alliance as compared to Jayalalithaa's that turned the results in his favour and against her.

All fine and dandy. The analysis would make sense, except for one big assumption.

Gurumurthy blindly assumes that if Vijayakanth had aligned with the ADMK, he would have won as many votes as he ended up winning. That, to me, is a big and unreasonable assumption. The main reason why people voted for Vijayakanth was that he was different, he didn't align himself with either of the Dravidian parties, he provided an alternative, idealistic it may be.

Imagine Vijayakanth turning an ADMK supporter, simply praising Jayalalitha in his speeches and asking people to vote for ADMK. Would his credibility have taken a beating? Absolutely. Would he have been relegated to the likes of Vaiko and Sarathkumar? Probably. Would he have won these many votes? No, I don't think so.

Links to this post

What next?

You can also bookmark this post using your favorite bookmarking service:

Related Posts by Categories



6 comments: to “ Gurumurthy on the Vijayakanth factor


  •  

    It may not be 171 Seats as opined by Gurumurthy but Vijaykanth factor would certainly have helped ADMK to retain power.

  • Bay Area Dravidan

     

    Man..

    U brahmins..no matter whatever happens..u support BJP and ADMK..coz their leaders are brahmins..

    Get a hold of reality dudes..can Jayalalitha tell a word against dravidian movement? Can she utter a word against reservation? Fact is TN (even India is following suit now) will always be ruled by anti/Non brahmins...U cannot change that.."Murpagal Seiyin Pirpagal Vizhayum" ..u r reaping the benefits of what your forefathers did to poor dravidians..


  •  

    I think it is not more of the Brahmin factor,For instance..she has arrested the Hindu spiritual leader and brought this entire nation / hinduism which has been there for millions of years, unlike the christians/Islams community they dont even permit their pope/prophet to be put into such a situation, infact they would have assasinated or would have never get things beyond their control and put their religion/ nation and religion to shame, but I think it is a bold step , but I also think it needs further investigation !!!
    you see the dravidian movements are mearly for vote..they propagate tamilzh, but see their children studying in Convents or mostly abroad, and also they say dont follow this ritual and that ritual but when it comes to their own family for instance death of leader maran they did follow rituals, do you think it is correct on them , but advises are always for others and not for them..that is what we as tamilian follow..I am neither a pro nor an anti aidmk/dmk..I am a general person who is concerned about this nation than religion.
    because religion was the earlier modes of spreading good virtues to humanity and bring discipline..during the olden centuries..which is no more applicable ..so as humans we have to rationalize and act in the internet age, instead of being biased by the fake !!!!
    JaiHind.


  •  

    I think it is not more of the Brahmin factor,For instance..she has arrested the Hindu spiritual leader and brought this entire nation / hinduism which has been there for millions of years, unlike the christians/Islams community they dont even permit their pope/prophet to be put into such a situation, infact they would have assasinated or would have never get things beyond their control and put their religion/ nation and religion to shame, but I think it is a bold step , but I also think it needs further investigation !!!
    you see the dravidian movements are mearly for vote..they propagate tamilzh, but see their children studying in Convents or mostly abroad, and also they say dont follow this ritual and that ritual but when it comes to their own family for instance death of leader maran they did follow rituals, do you think it is correct on them , but advises are always for others and not for them..that is what we as tamilian follow..I am neither a pro nor an anti aidmk/dmk..I am a general person who is concerned about this nation than religion.
    because religion was the earlier modes of spreading good virtues to humanity and bring discipline..during the olden centuries..which is no more applicable ..so as humans we have to rationalize and act in the internet age, instead of being biased by the fake !!!!
    JaiHind.

  • Anonymous

     

    You have an outstanding good and well structured site. I enjoyed browsing through it
    tamiflu lexus es 330 virgin islands bird and flower acyclovir skin care modafinil wellbutrin weight female body builders wwwcom gps child watch stargate home automation interior decorate of beach houses jeep chrysler mod retro sofas couches for sale free shipping london free term insurance quotes

  • Anonymous

     

    Looking for information and found it at this great site... »